EContentmag.com Home
Newsletter
EContent Xtra
EContent Blog
Research Centers
Content Commerce
Content Creation & Digital Publishing
Content Delivery
Content Distribution
Content Integration
Content Management
Content Security
Digital Asset Management
Fee-Based Information Services
Intranets and Portals
KM & Collaboration
Mobile & Wireless Content
News/Finance/Business
Online Community
Rich Media
Sci-Tech/Medical
Search Technology
Taxonomy
Web Services


Columns
After Thought
Agile Minds
Behind the Firewall
Edit This
Eureka
Flexing Your Content
Follow the Money
Guest Columns
I Column Like I CM
Info Insider
Info Pro
Media Redux
Screen Play
Technology Watch

Departments
Case Studies
eReader
Faces of EContent
Peopleware

In Focus
EContent 100
EContent 100 Videos
Past Issues

Services
About EContent
Advertising
Subscribe to
EContent Magazine
EContent Xtra
Newsletters
Solutions Directory
RSS Feeds from EContentMag.comFeeds


A Case of Improving the Peer-Review Process
By Sue Marquette Poremba - July/August 2010 Issue, Posted Jul 26, 2010 Bookmark and Share Print Version   Page 1 of 3 next »

Marion Waldman began Albany, N.Y.-based iD8 Publishing Services in 2005. The company is a vendor for the educational publishing industry, providing a full range of services that take the customer through the early phases of production. Waldman, who partners with Triple SSS Press Media Development, uses a dual approach to each project, integrating editorial and marketing to work in tandem. iD8 also provides online services.

www.id8publishing.com

Business Challenge
An integral part of academic publishing is peer review, which ensures the quality and integrity of a book or journal. However, based on her past experiences, Waldman knew peer review is rarely an efficient process, largely because of the long periods of time involved in collecting reviews or "slice and dice" comments to make decisions regarding information. A first-edition book project, for example, may require up to eight unique reviewers per chapter. Waldman wanted to find an efficient online system that could manage large amounts of qualitative data that could generate reports for authors.

QSR International
QSR International provides a qualitative research software platform that assists researchers to not only manage information easily but, as CEO John Owen explains, to extract wisdom out of the information. Its premier product is NVivo, which is used to analyze the different data available in research materials. The Melbourne, Australia, company has been in business for 15 years.


www.qsrinternational.com


The Problem in Depth
Marion Waldman worked in the academic and educational publishing for 20 years before deciding to going into business for herself in 2005. Thanks to her experience, she knew there was often a disconnect between editorial and marketing and believed that the two areas need to work together in order to create a successful end product.

Peer review is vital to educational and scientific publishing, not only for the quality of content but also for seeding the market for future sales. As Waldman began to take on large, first-edition projects, she found she had to subcontract the peer-review process. "As the person managing the project, I couldn't work with the content and do project management and take care of all the details required in handling the review process," she explains.

She was also frustrated with the lack of services out there to manage the review process. One company she found allowed reviewers to go online to perform a quantitative review online and provide a grade. However, she found that the grading system was demoralizing to the authors. "It's one thing to give a student a ‘C,' but the authors didn't like getting one," she laughs.

The bottom line, she adds, is that there was no report. While you could read the different aspects of the review and the grade, there was nothing to turn over to the authors or that could be used to allow her to make editorial decisions.

"I felt like there had to be something out there that could manage large amounts of qualitative data so that we could turn over qualitative reports," she says.

What she had hoped to find was something that reviewers could access online and could help them easily pull together custom reports, as well as databases that can tie reviewers to reviewer quotes for sales managers. "I wanted to be able to synchronize all of the information we have," Waldman says.


Bookmark and Share Print Version   Page 1 of 3 next »
Search EContent:
25,000+ articles now available in ITI's new full-text digital archive: ITI-InfoCentral.com!
Visit ITI's Enterprise Search Center!
CURRENT ISSUE

Subscribe today!
directory
»   Read the 15 minute guide to Enterprise Content Management
»   Read the 15-Minute Guide to Best Practices in Correspondence Management
»   ITIResearch.com - A collection of market research and reports for executive management and business & IT professionals
»   Need instructional help with Online Video? Check out our new resource - OnlineVideo.net
»   EMC Live Webcast: 10 Signs That You Can Increase Knowledge Worker Productivity Wed. Sept. 15, 2010, 9:00 am PT / 12:00 pm ET / 17:00 BST. Register Now

All Content Copyright © 1998 - 2010, Online: a Division of Information Today Inc.
48 South Main St., Suite 3 · Newtown, CT 06470-2140
(203) 761-1466, (800) 248-8466 · Fax (203) 304-9300 · custserv@infotoday.com
PRIVACY POLICY